Subscribe to The Brown Daily Herald Newsletter

Sign up for The Brown Daily Herald’s daily newsletter to stay up to date with what is happening at Brown and on College Hill no matter where you are right now!



Moffat ’13: U.S. drug policies are a crime against humanity

Opinions Editor
Friday, February 17, 2012


It is a very unfortunate fact that many otherwise savvy and socially aware Brunonians tend to assume that drug policy is a relatively minor issue in politics. The disturbing truth is that our drug laws, and the institutions that carry out the intent of those laws, constitute nothing less than a campaign of fear, corruption, violence and mind-control — it is a war after all. With citizens’ tax dollars, these massive infrastructures — which include prisons, police officers, propaganda programs, the military, the Drug Enforcement Administration and so on — are given the task of stamping out the consumption of drugs. Yet, for more than 40 years now, the war on drugs has failed in its mission. We are currently in the longest and most destructive war in American history, and yet no one seems to want to talk about it.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with our current federal drug policies, the basic idea is pretty simple. The government uses five “schedules” to classify drugs according to three properties — “potential for abuse,” “accepted medical use” and potential to lead to “psychological or physical dependence.” Schedule I drugs, for example, are deemed by the DEA and the Food and Drug Administration to have a high potential for abuse, no accepted medical value and a high potential for dependence. This most serious category currently includes drugs like marijuana, LSD, psilocybin and MDMA.

However, concerning the four drugs I just mentioned, legitimate research conducted by third-parties and the government itself has consistently shown this classification system to be utterly spurious. According to a 2010 British study published in the Lancet, these particular substances are actually some of the least harmful of all recreational drugs. Their impact on society and potential for addiction is miniscule compared with alcohol and tobacco — which, of course, are entirely legal. 

On top of that, more evidence confirming the medical benefits of Schedule I drugs surfaces every day. The American College of Physicians recently published a paper in which they recommend further research on marijuana for the treatment of nausea, glaucoma, neurological disorders and pain. LSD and psilocybin have proven effective in treating cluster headaches, a condition that affects one in 1,000 people and is so painful it has earned the nickname “suicide headache.” Research has also shown that MDMA can effectively treat post-traumatic stress disorder.  

The real knife in the back is that this blatantly inaccurate system of classification is the legal justification for the state’s use of violence against its own people. According to 2011 statistics, more than half of all federal prisoners are serving sentences for drug-related offenses. This, in addition to the fact that the United States incarcerates more people per capita than any other country and that a disproportionate number of these prisoners are black or Hispanic, provides sufficient grounds for charging the U.S. with crimes against humanity. 

Particularly sickening is the fact that this prison-industrial complex is completely subsidized by John Q. Taxpayer. Harvard economist Jeffrey Miron estimates that state and federal governments spend more than $48 billion a year fighting the war on drugs. 

And let’s not forget the obvious detail that making drugs illegal doesn’t get rid of drugs. Outlawing them simply creates an extremely lucrative black market, since criminal gangs derive the exclusive right to deal. The profitability of selling illegal drugs acts like a magnet that uproots hundreds of thousands of teens from their communities every year and lures them into a life of crime. And the violence created by our drug laws is certainly not entirely contained within our borders. Drug cartels in Latin America, fueled by our guns and our money, have murdered thousands of innocent people and continue to destabilize the region in their quest to supply our demand for illegal drugs. 

To solve the problem, our government doles out more of your hard-earned cash in the form of “aid” — that is, weaponry and combat training — to these countries, enabling the U.S. to fight a proxy war, thus exporting the externalities created by this thriving industry of violence. 

Even if we won this war on drugs, it still demonstrates what hypocrites we really are. Think about it for a second — what liberty is more fundamental than the right to explore and experiment with one’s own consciousness? If, while under the influence of drugs, I steal a car or assault someone, I’m going to be punished for that wrongdoing regardless. What, then, are the grounds for making drug use itself a crime? If the logic is that it’s the state’s duty to shape the moral conscious and worldview of its citizenry — well then, hello, 1984. 

I want to support President Obama, but as long as he continues to enable these atrocities, he’s a coward in my book. And on this issue Republicans really display their talent for doublespeak ­— I thought conservatives liked individual freedom, small government and fiscal responsibility? As we listen to criticism of governments like Syria for enacting violent and persecutory campaigns against its own citizens, we ought to pause and reflect on our own crimes against humanity. 



Jared Moffat ’13 is a philosophy concentrator from Jackson, Miss. He can be contacted at

To stay up-to-date, subscribe to our daily newsletter.

  1. The true crimes against humanity are taking place now, not against the ‘illegal drugs’ as much as, against the pain and psychiatric patients and the medical establishment that still, lessening by the moment, attempts true provide the adequate medical services. The more odious than the idiotic war on the drugs like the LSD, (and there’s absolutely no reason no single out Marijuanna here; the war against cocaine or heroine is just as rediculous), — is the cpmtimous outlawing, or ‘de facto’ so, i.e. never letting to prescribe, of the medications that are well tolerated and, in fact, helpful to the patients, while re-placing them with the either totally worthless new creations with artificially integrated (!) side-effects (like the ‘mood stabilizers) or simply, with the out-right poisons like the dopamine-blockers which are now quietly instilled anywhere amd everywhere, given out like candy, in various strengths, are even over-the-counter, like Dramamine and Maclesine. And that’s after their fore-father Haldol and Thorazine have over 5 million deaths, directely attributable. I say, screw the ‘forums” and the referendums’, there’s nothing to talk about, there’s not one legitamite reason for any segment of this demented drug war. —
    — All drugs must be legal and de-regulated; those responsible for this longest and dumbest witch-hunt must be punished with the at-most severity, the restitutions to those suffered must be paid.
    Use drugs everywhere and any way you want; fight those who try to stop or arrest you like u would fight any bandit or a homocidal maniac, no matter what they’re dressed in and what ID’s and badges they carry. U have the right to pursue happiness that’s yours. U’re a freedom fighter, if only your own freedom, after all.

Comments are closed. If you have corrections to submit, you can email The Herald at