University News

Panelists condemn racial profiling

Diverse panel discusses problems in police treatment of people of color, Muslims

Senior Staff Writer
Wednesday, March 11, 2015

“Our criminal justice system is a bias and a broken system,” said Chris Burbank, chief of police at the Salt Lake City Police Department, during a panel entitled “Police Profiling: Causes and Consequences” Tuesday evening.

About 40 community members gathered to hear three panelists speak about racial profiling, policing bias, incarceration, police brutality and surveillance.

The first panelist, Farhana Khera, president and executive director of Muslim Advocates, an organization that seeks to end religious and racial profiling, centered her discussion on the aftermath of Sept. 11. 9/11 triggered a law enforcement response that reshaped the nation, Khera said.

Since the attack, the Federal Bureau of Investigation has been spying on individuals based on their religious faith without any probable cause, she said. By 2005, the FBI had conducted about 500,000 “voluntary interviews” of Muslim individuals, “but not one of these interviews resulted in information that could prevent a terrorist attack,” she added.

“If the federal government is working this way, what does this signal to the state?” Khera asked.

Following Khera, the other two panelists shifted the focus of the talk to the relation between policing, incarceration and race.

Though crimes and drug abuse are present in every demographic, people of color are incarcerated at a much higher rate, Burbank said.

Not only are people of color more likely to be arrested, but they are also more likely to be killed by law enforcement — the likelihood for young black males is 21 times higher than that for their white peers, said Heather Thompson, professor of history and African American studies at Temple University.

This statistic stems from ideas about who is perceived as a criminal as well as realities of which neighborhoods are policed, she said.

Police are also expected to uphold racialized laws, Thompson said, citing the 10 to one disparity between crack and powder cocaine sentence laws as an example.

While incarceration in the U.S. remains high, reintegration into society after serving jail time poses difficulties. “We have no avenue for (people) to find their way out of the system,” Thompson said. Sixty-seven percent of those arrested return to jail after they are released, often for the same category of crime, he said. “This is not success.”

“So should every crime that occurs end up in incarceration?” Burbank asked the audience. He responded to his own question by noting that more options for rehabiliatory programs and treatment would target underlying reasons for the crimes. From an economic standpoint, high incarceration is not a sound solution when 25 individuals cost the state of Utah $1 million, he added.

Joey Massa ’17, called the panel “great” because it explored the question of whether incarceration accomplishes what it should. The important follow-up question “is not what we can do, but what we should do,” Massa said, reiterating Burbank’s words.

The panel was presented by the Center for the Study of Race and Ethnicity and co-sponsored by the Taubman Center for Public Policy and the Watson Institute for International Studies.


  1. Must condemn fbi/police serial killers
    All fbi agents, police (and all of their operatives), judges, attorneys, officials and members of the community at large who engaged in crimes against me are de facto criminals and should be prosecuted. They will not be held accountable because the country is in the grips of an horrendous police state that threatens all of us in one way or another.

    The evidence that I have collected applies to my situation, but in a sense reflects as well the corrupt and murderous mentality that dominates the entire society with regards to the gross mistreatments of all who become (or are about to become) Targets under any circumstances (including those who are stopped by cops for routine inquiry). In the links below I offer de facto and prima facie criminal cases against those fbi, police, judges, attorneys, chancellors, and members of society who participated in or aided the thugs of the fbi in their illegal vendetta against me. Here are the links with a brief description of each:

    The fbi’s overall operation against me authorized by a corrupt and insane judge/operative in efforts to silence me from reporting their multiple and ongoing felonies:

    US Postal Inspector crimes and cover ups in support of the fbi assassins:

    My affidavits against the Postal Inspector and Texas DPS Agent Rodriguez for their conspiracy to illegally harass, intimidate, threaten, or arrest me:

    Crimes by the fbi:

    My explanation of why the fbi engages in their vendetta against me:

    Fraudulent Bolo issued against me by the foolish, retarded and corrupt UT police:

    Provocative assault on my person as orchestrated by UT police and fbi in their efforts to find a way to arrest me on campus:

    My paper on the complete corruption of the CJS by the fbi and their hideous and cowardly friends at CJIS:

Leave a Reply to geral sosbee Cancel

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *