Subscribe to The Brown Daily Herald Newsletter

Sign up for The Brown Daily Herald’s daily newsletter to stay up to date with what is happening at Brown and on College Hill no matter where you are right now!


Metro, News

Brown community reacts to insurrection at Capitol

Some students and faculty call for President Trump’s removal

Metro Editor
Friday, January 8, 2021
A blue flag reading 'trump train' waving in front of the US Capitol

In a presumed attempt to stop the Congressional certification of the Electoral College votes, the rioters stormed the building, vandalizing and taking selfies as they went, many carrying flags with Trump slogans.

Following an insurrection in the U.S. Capitol, the Brown community, including groups across the political spectrum, united in condemning the Jan. 6 incident.

“Disgusting is the word that keeps coming to mind,” Visiting Professor of the Practice of Political Science Richard Arenberg, who worked for over 34 years as a staffer in the Senate, told The Herald. “It’s really totally unprecedented.” Arenberg is a professor of the practice of political science and interim director of the Taubman Center for American Politics and Policy. 

President Trump’s supporters, encouraged by the president in a rally earlier that day to march to the U.S. Capitol to contest the outcome of the election, broke through barricades and bypassed police Wednesday afternoon. In a presumed attempt to stop the Congressional certification of the Electoral College votes, the rioters stormed the building, vandalizing and taking selfies as they went. Members of Congress and congressional staff were evacuated.

Four people died, and more than 50 Capitol Police and metropolitan police were injured.

In an email to the University community, President Christina Paxson P’19 described yesterday’s events as “abhorrent.” 

“Although I am confident these efforts won’t be successful, they are a reminder that democracy is precious but fragile,” she wrote. “We may take it for granted, but we shouldn’t.”  

Students who spoke to The Herald expressed disgust at the shows of violence on display at the seat of American democracy.

Lucas Gelfond ’23.5 told The Herald he felt anger watching the events unfold on television, both at the rioters and at the police who failed to stop them. He said he saw videos on social media of a police officer taking a selfie with a rioter, and another of a police officer helping a Trump supporter down the steps of the Capitol.

The most striking images to him, Gelfond said, were those comparing the police presence Wednesday to that at Black Lives Matter protests over the summer. “This feels like law enforcement responded to this in such a different way, based on at least what seemed to me to be the skin color of the protesters,” Gelfond said. “That was really disheartening.”

Gelfond said he was not surprised that something like the insurgence at the Capitol would happen, given that President Trump “deeply encouraged” violence, in his view. 

Student political organizations also condemned the insurrection in the Capitol. 

Brown Votes, a Swearer Center for Public Service student group that advocates for voter registration and civic engagement, wrote in a statement that acts of violence in the Capitol “jeopardize every American’s ability to fully participate in our government.”

In a statement, Brown College Republicans called the insurrection “an attempted coup on the republic that our founding fathers fought to establish,” and said that “we must accept the people’s will and the results of the 2020 election.” 

The group, which endorsed Trump for reelection, placed blame for the violence squarely on the president. “By misleading many American citizens into believing that the 2020 election was rigged or stolen and in turn inciting violence on the Capitol, President Trump demonstrated that he stands between America and a free, fair democracy,” the statement said.

But not all members of the Brown College Republicans agreed with assigning blame to Trump, according to the club’s president, Jessica McDonald ’21. “There is debate between club members about the role of President Trump and how much, if any, responsibility lies with him,” she wrote in a message to The Herald.

In their own statement, the College Democrats of Rhode Island, a coalition of Democratic groups from colleges around the state, called for Trump’s removal from office, either by Vice President Mike Pence invoking the 25th Amendment or by Congress impeaching the president. The group commended Rep. David Cicilline, D-RI, who circulated a letter Wednesday afternoon calling for Pence to invoke the 25th Amendment.

“President Trump abdicated responsibility for his office today by expressing his love for domestic terrorists and continuing to peddle dangerous lies about the 2020 election and our democratic process,” the College Democrats wrote. “As young people concerned with the future of our nation, we remind you that nothing less than the survival of our democracy is at stake.”

Jasmine Powell ’22, president of the Brown College Democrats, said she thinks the attack on the Capitol was “the culmination of so much.” Powell pointed to Trump’s rhetoric as the source of Wednesday’s violence, but admitted that the hatred that Trump tapped into is not new.

“A lot of the underlying hatred that people have that led them to go out there (Wednesday) has been around for years,” Powell said.

At a rally at the National Mall just prior to the attack on the Capitol, Trump, while spouting false claims about the results of the election, urged his supporters to “walk down to the Capitol,” adding that “we are going to have to fight so much harder.” 

Powell reiterated others’ calls for Trump to be removed from office through the 25th Amendment or impeachment by Congress. If Trump is not removed from office, she said she believes Congress will be complicit in the violence incited by Trump. 

In a video posted on his Twitter account Thursday night, Trump said that a “new administration” would be sworn in Jan. 20, effectively conceding the election to President-elect Joe Biden for the first time.

Multiple faculty members also called for Trump’s removal. A letter written by professors Brendan Nyhan and John Carey at Dartmouth and signed by hundreds of political scientists, described President Trump as “unwilling or unable to fulfill his oath.”

“The President’s actions threaten American democracy,” the letter says. “Our profession seeks to understand politics, not engage in it, but we share a commitment to democratic values.” University professors Jonathan Collins, Ross Cheit, Bonnie Honig and Robert Blair signed the letter.

“This is so much bigger than just a news headline,” Collins, assistant professor of education, told The Herald. “This is something that could determine whether or not we become more democratic or spiral into authoritarianism.”

Collins said that Trump’s rhetoric “opens a can of worms” for future elections and raises concerns that whichever party loses in the future may not accept the results. When democracy does not have a peaceful transfer of power, Collins said, “we lose the essence of what democracy is.”

To stay up-to-date, subscribe to our daily newsletter.

  1. Those rioters missed a perfectly good opportunity to tear down all those evil oppressive statues standing in the National Statuary Hall!

  2. they were peacefully establishing a capital autonomous zone while practicing their first amendment right.

  3. “People will do what they do” – Nancy Pelosi.

  4. alum commenter says:

    This just profiles blue tribe members as they bond over their disdain for the red tribe. It’s all that horrible red tribe’s fault that we can’t have nice things, and really, can you believe how terrible they all are? We should depose their captain, that would teach them!

    To me, The Capital Hill affair seems like just another iteration in a series of reckless provocations in the culture wars. Experience shows that every time one side escalates, the other side retaliates, and the situation worsens. If you think that only the red (or blue) tribe is playing this game, then you’re part of the problem. We all need to step back now, take a deep breath, and commit to de-escalation. There’s no real alternative; marginalizing the entire opposition isn’t achievable (or desirable.)

    • Eugene Icks says:

      In short: you’re with Trump when he declared that “there were very fine people on both sides,” when on one side, there were Nazis — actual, swastika-waving, “Jews will not replace us,” Nazis. You belong to those people who were appeasers in the 1930s — gathered in the “America First” group, dedicated to appeasing the Nazis. And, what a coincidence, “America First” was Trump’s favorite slogan.

    • Never True says:

      Yup, that’s pretty much it. Maybe I missed that particular issue of the BDH, but I don’t recall reading about any hand-wringing or teeth-nashing amongst the denizens of College Hill when folks were occupying government buildings in Portland and Seattle or attempting to bust into the Supreme Court building to prevent Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation. I guess those weren’t threats to democracy. Maybe all the wise professors quoted in this article can enlighten the rest of us hoi polloi as to when it’s okay to occupy government buildings, assault representatives of law enforcement and burn things down and when destruction of private and public property is actually not violence at all but just the cry of the marginalized and disenfranchised oppressed masses straining against the chains of capitalism, imperialism, etc.

      • Eugene Icks says:

        Aside from your absurd and baseless exaggerations, you might want to do a little remedial work on basic morality – in particular, “two wrongs don’t make a right.” Perhaps a little refresher stay in kindergarten?

  5. Pissed Off By Double Standards says:

    Please stop sidestepping the issue and call it what it was: a terrorist attack!

    In 1967 the Black panthers were shut down for doing the exact same thing, but for resources in the community such as soup kitchens, food pantries, medical clinics, better schools, better programs for women and children, and to demand the Black community stop being targeted by the police, a very just cause. They weren’t called “insurrections”, they were branded violent mob gang super predators. Yet, this group terrorizes lawmakers at the Capitol for protesting a constitutionally elected president and the same labels are not applied to them. The most salient difference is the color of their skin.

    Brown Daily Herald, you can do better than this! Stop following the mainstream medias apologist propaganda and call them what they are: terrorists!!!

Leave a Reply to Never True Cancel

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *